The Panamagate Judgement. Another open letter to the Supreme Court bench.

The Panamagate Judgement.
Another open letter to the Supreme Court bench.

By Syed Haider Raza Mehdi.

Dear Lordships,

Thank you for hearing this case and keeping the nation engaged, these past two months.

Today most Pakistanis, barring some who recently left post haste for the UK, including First Daughter, and dear First Father recently in Turkey, look askance at two institutions. The Supreme court, specifically Your lordships and that “Saviour of the last resort” the Pakistan Army, to somehow initiate the process of getting this poor country, back on track.

Not the Red Line track or Green line track or the Metro track or Orange train track, or the Motorway track or the many other tracks representing the loot, plunder, pillage and corruption that has beset this wretched land.

But the track of accountability, honesty, meritocracy, competence, equitable access to safety of life, property, health care, education and jobs and all other opportunities.

The track of tolerance and accommodation to live with people of contrarian views, faiths and beliefs.

A track where people have hope of a better tomorrow. So that they do not fall prey to purveyors of grossly misinterpreted religious thought.

And perhaps most critically, a track of honest, competent, patriotic leadership who do not sell their souls and the country for Qatari dinars.

I’m not a lawyer, nor any pretensions of being one, so clearly not in any position to offer any legal insights.

But some things that your lordships said when you “Mahfoozed” your order are worrying.

Its the kind of stuff we in the Corporate world call a “CMA” or a “CMB” statement.  In more polite words, its a way to pre empt any future uproar and ensure that all honorable backsides are fully covered.

You said, we will judge by “Law” and the “Constitution”. Mighty fine words, your Lordships.  Mighty fine!

But there is something called the “Letter” of the law and the “Spirit” of the law.  Something called the “Words” of the Constitution and something called the “Intent” of the Constitution.  In both cases it’s the “Interest” of the Country and the People of Pakistan that must remain paramount.

We ask for the “Spirit” of the law and the “Intent” of the Constitution. We ask that Justice be served and what is good for the people of Pakistan and not let this case fall victim to “technicalities” of the “Law” and the ” Constitution”.

Enough hints were dropped by your Lordships on the “admissibility” of the evidence, its “validity” and its “sources”.

This is scary, your Lordships. Very scary!

If today, with all that we have seen, heard and read, with everything that we know of the Panama Gate, irrespective of its “admissibility” in your august court, if even now, in your eyes, there is even the remotest semblance of doubt about the criminality of Nawaz Sharif, his family, Ishaq Dar  and all those who were part of these terrible acts, then, I’m afraid,  your Lordships, we are doomed!

If Nawaz Sharif and his cohort of looters and plunderers headed by Ishaq Dar, get away with this kind of brazen daylight robbery and murder of all that is honest, ethical and moral, then we are indeed doomed, your honour, and honorably and royally screwed! (please pardon the French)

Short of catching Nawaz Sharif, riding atop a Camel and leading a line of camels from Dubai to Qatar, with 12 million US$ laden atop them, we cannot have more clear evidence of his guilt and loot and plunder.

Please do not pass the buck to a “Commission”. As your Lordships so rightly said. No institution in this country could catch these guys because he has bought off everybody. Everybody.

Look at that Qamar chap, the NAB Chairman. A person better hauled in chains. But he has the bloody audacity to give all of you Honourable Lordships, the proverbial up yours finger, in the Court.

That is how powerful Nawaz Sharif has become that this crook and his minions can look you all squarely in the eye with contempt, saying…..Do what you can……

 So which person and what institution will conduct the inquiries for this Commission?

We do not have time.  Our country is being milked dry.  The Barbarians are at the gates and all over inside. There is no one to help except your Lordships.  Asking the Army is calling for Martial law and we all know where that leads us.

Paraphrasing Henry II, For God’s sake your Lordships, help rid us and Pakistan of these terribly evil and corrupt people.

Otherwise like a cancer they will emerge even stronger, spread like wildfire, till there is, God Forbid, no Pakistan.

The Lahore Tragedy -13 Feb 17- Nothing will change until the ‘Thought’ is choked

By Syed Haider Raza Mehdi

My heart bleeds for the innocent dead and injured. Victims of an insanity which has gripped Muslims all across the globe and not just Pakistan.

What do you expect when billions of dollars are used to indoctrinate impressionable minds with religious texts which are distorted, misinterpreted, taken out of context to suit a particular version of the faith?

How do you undo the madness which in our recent history started in 1975 and is still ongoing?

How do you tell this teeming mass of unemployed, poverty stricken, exploited and desperate humanity in Pakistan that they have a better future?

What a tragic comedy that we have “deradicalization” centers in Fata and KPK which “deradicalize former terrorists” and then we let them back into a highly radicalized society?

Our salvation lies in addressing this challenge on many fronts.

One is clearly better governance which provides hope and succor to the deprived and exploited who fall easy victim and become easy fodder for these purveyors of “Heaven”.

Another is to take back our mosques and madrassas and schools and colleges and universities and media from the clutches of those who promote this terrible poison disguised as religious discourse.

We must address the four key factors which enable militancy and terrorism.

1. The “Thought and belief systems” which drive this.

2. The cause which provides the “objective” the group wants to achieve.

3. 3M. The Money, Men and Materials which equips them to sustain and carry out these attacks.

4. The physical space used by these groups to rest, regroup, survive.

The “Thought” which drives this behaviour vests in an extremely distorted, misinterpreted, misapplied theological framework developed by an 18th Century cleric in the Arabian peninsula and which today is their official religious creed.

Starting in 1975 and still continuing to this day, this violent thought has been aggressively exported to Muslim countries and communities  across the globe backed by over 100 billion petro dollars.

It was further radicalized by 40 years of war in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, and is now rampant across the Muslim Middle East and Pakistan and in misguided Muslim youth in North America and Europe.

In Pakistan, we have to take back and snatch back, even through brute force all forums and pulpits through which this thought is disseminated to our youth.

Our homes are under threat as these purveyors cunningly use religious Dawa circles and so called “Religious classes” to push through a virulent restrictive misinterpretation of our great religion. They target mothers and women in the house so they can indoctrinate entire future generations.

A main stream private sector media channel allows prime time to a silky tongue lady preacher representative of that school whose “Religious Empire” extends all across the country luring unsuspecting women.

But we can only do that if we have a strong representative, competent government of integrity.

Our public governance is incredibly weak and fragile. Our institutions, ineffective and toothless because of corrupt politicians and repeated martial laws.

Our current Prime Minister and his daughter are only concerned about avoiding conviction in the Panama Case.  They are totally oblivious, unconcerned and thick skinned to the moral and ethical imperatives of their conduct and guilt.

How can such compromised people provide the leadership this nation needs at this time?

The cause of a Pan Islamic Global Caliphate is of course a mirage but is an extremely powerful magnet for a wide eyed highly testosteroned and angry Muslim young man living in either marginalized societies like Pakistan and most of the wretched world called “Muslim Countries” or a confused individual in Europe or North America with a confused identity.

Not knowing whether he or she is Muslim or Pakistani or Jat or Awan or Rajput or Pathan or Sindhii or Mohajir  or American or Canadian or British etc. Their parents don’t inderstand them, nor speak the language of their adopted lands.

And this lost soul confused about his identity and where he belongs, finds solace and an identity as a “Radical Muslim” in the fiery rhetoric and poison spewed from the pulpits of mosques in London, Birmingham, New York, Chicago, Frankfurt, Toronto etc funded by “Brotherly Islamic countries”.

In our own country, Pakistan, they are subjected to a daily barrage of ‘Religosity” in their homes, schools, colleges, universities. In mosques. In workplaces. In sports. In Entertainment. On TV.

Its so easy to showcase an iconic celebrity who now sports a beard or an anchor who now wears a Hijab. Suddenly tens if not hundreds of thousands are inspired towards Religosity.  Which isn’t the problem and nothing wrong with people becoming religious. But when these impressionable people get into the hands of those who are working towards this “one world caliphate” it’s easy for them to become “Soldiers of Allah”.

Even if they don’t become suicide bombers or violent militants, these “born again zealots” now harbour latent and even overt hatred towards other sects and religions.

And not only are the young overwhelmed with this massive rebranding of Muslim belief, but the middle aged, the elderly, the suave educated urban banker, the corporate professional, the businessman, the college and university teacher, the doctors and engineers. All getting swept away in this tidal wave of religious extremist thought backed by massive relentless indoctrination with unlimited funding.

But what keeps these groups alive and healthy is the funding and financing which gives them the intellectual and physical assets of men, materials, equipments and the weapons to wreak havoc on us.

It is no secret now that the bulk of this financing comes from sources within Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait and Qatar. And from sources in Europe and North America. It also comes from those who want to keep us on the back foot. India definitely.  And most likely Afghanistan, Israel and the USA.

It is supplemented by willing and unwilling charitable donations from within Pakistan as well as the Pakistani expatriates and from criminal activities.

While we can stop sources from within Pakistan, i.e if Nawaz Sharif and Co can stop making deals and focus on the NAP.  But how do we tell our “Brotherly Islamic Countries” to stop exporting and funding this poison? And how do we stop it?

Poor weak and ineffective governments like ours, cede the physical space to these elements to operate with impunity. Our government does not have the competence nor the ability nor the institutional depth, and most tragically, neither the intent to fight them and take back this space.

The Lahore Tragedy is an example of this incompetence.

Post script to my earlier article.

P.S.
The subsequent terror bombings in KPK, Baluchistan and Sehwan’s Sharif in Sind, is a clear message by these terrorists that they can and will target both rural and urban Pakistan.

Pakistan is in a state of war and massive terrorist attacks. Yet it does not have a comprehensive Counter Terrorism Strategy, nor strong institutions capable of execution. NAP is dead or dying under the “able” hands of the interior minister. NACTA is toothless, under resourced and underfunded and without the right  leadership.

But most importantly and tragically we have weak, corrupt and compromised leadership, completely at sea on what to do.

A Prime minister under serious charges of corruption, money laundering, misusing authority for personal gain. But bent on foisting his equally corrupt and compromised daughter on the nation and his party as his heir apparent. Very similar to the North Korean model

Ishaq Dar, the finance minister, a self confessed money launderer doesnt have the funds to resource our counter terrorism strategy and equip our law enforcement agencies. But has the resources to fund projects where  the kickbacks thrive.

Recently we witnessed perhaps the most brazen and misuse of public office and authority when Ishaq Dar sold 500 Million $ Pakistani bonds at 8% interest in the international market.

The entire tranche, of course behind several layers of legal secrecy, as in the Panama case were purchased  by Nawaz Sharif and family. Not only do they have the 500 million dollars (they have a lot more) but now they have an investment which pays them 8% interest backed by the sovereign guarantee of the Pakistani Government. Alhamdulillah what a master stroke between Nawaz and Samdhi.

The Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, more comfortable in abusing the army, wearing Saville row suits and an eye for the more bohemian things in life (not a bad thing) is completely at sea on defence matters and is clearly not consulted nor interested. And also not on speaking terms with his fellow cabinet colleague, the Interior Minister.

Ch. Nisar, the interior minister, is a master at double speak and hypocrisy. On the one hand he owns the Counter terrorism National Action plan, yet he sits snugly  with terrorists in his office and provides them and their public rallies, full  police protection. All of them are officially banned and proscribed  as known sectarian terrorist organizations by the Government of Pakistan.  Yet he calls these banned terror outfits  “not as bad”.

But his wrath and anger and the “uncompromising” writ of the state comes down heavily on Valentine’s day balloon sellers.

So there you have it, as clear as day and the very limited options we have under the current leaders.

To move forward there is an immediate need for a change of government, if we can even begin the task of putting things right.

Otherwise hold tight, it’s a tragic slippery slope